Man prescribed emotional support dog faces eviction for having a ‘pet’

Christopher Palmer outside the Plymouth Crown Court in Devon, with his dog Tammy. 26/11/2019 See SWNS story SWSYevict. A vulnerable man has been hauled to court and faces eviction over his medically prescribed 'emotional support companion dog' - despite doctors demanding he be allowed to keep it. Christopher Palmer, 63, has suffered years of depression, anxiety and mental health problems - leaving him socially isolated with suicidal tendencies. But things changed when Christopher's doctor prescribed him an emotional support and mental wellness animal companion - a beagle called Tammy in December 2018. Despite Christopher's pet being prescribed by a doctor, when Plymouth Community Homes found out, they ordered the dog had to be rehomed.
Christopher Palmer, 63, says he wouldn’t be able to leave the house without his beagle Tammy (Picture: SWNS)

A man with severe mental health issues faces eviction after doctors prescribed him an emotional support dog.

Christopher Palmer, 63, has suffered through years of depression, anxiety and other psychological problems. His issues have left him socially isolated with suicidal tenancies, but his life changed in 2018 when he got Tammy. His beagle helps him through anxiety and panic attacks, with Mr Palmer stating: ‘Without Tammy I would not be able to get out of the house’.
However, when Plymouth Community Homes found out about the dog, they ordered that she be re-homed as Christopher is not permitted to keep a pet. The landlord says Christopher is in breach of his tenancy agreement which states he is not permitted to keep a dog as he lives in a high rise flat, according to their pet policy.

However, if he refuses to give away Tammy, Christopher will have to move out of his home of eight years too.

Christopher Palmer outside the Plymouth Crown Court in Devon, with his dog Tammy. 26/11/2019 See SWNS story SWSYevict. A vulnerable man has been hauled to court and faces eviction over his medically prescribed 'emotional support companion dog' - despite doctors demanding he be allowed to keep it. Christopher Palmer, 63, has suffered years of depression, anxiety and mental health problems - leaving him socially isolated with suicidal tendencies. But things changed when Christopher's doctor prescribed him an emotional support and mental wellness animal companion - a beagle called Tammy in December 2018. Despite Christopher's pet being prescribed by a doctor, when Plymouth Community Homes found out, they ordered the dog had to be rehomed.
His mental health issues have left him socially isolated with suicidal tenancies (Picture: SWNS)

There is a section in the Plymouth Community Homes Pets Policy that explains pets are allowed if they are medically prescribed.

Protect Your Dogs Paws in the Winter with Vaseline. If you don’t have any paw balm, and if your dog doesn’t like wearing boots, you can use some Vaseline to help protect your dogs paws in the winter.

PCH has said they would re-home both of them, however Christopher’s doctor has argued this would make his condition worse.

The case went to Plymouth County Court on Tuesday, but a judge gave Christopher a stay of execution, ordering that they could carry on living together until another hearing in January.

Speaking afterwards, Christopher said: ‘Without Tammy I would not be able to get out of the house.

‘I need to have her 24 hours a day. I suffer panic attacks and anxiety so I need to have her with me.

‘PCH should not be able to treat people with mental health the way they do.

‘They should treat people with a bit of respect. I cannot move to a new place as I have friends in the building who support me.

Christopher Palmer's dog Tammy outside the Plymouth Crown Court in Devon. 26/11/2019 See SWNS story SWSYevict. A vulnerable man has been hauled to court and faces eviction over his medically prescribed 'emotional support companion dog' - despite doctors demanding he be allowed to keep it. Christopher Palmer, 63, has suffered years of depression, anxiety and mental health problems - leaving him socially isolated with suicidal tendencies. But things changed when Christopher's doctor prescribed him an emotional support and mental wellness animal companion - a beagle called Tammy in December 2018. Despite Christopher's pet being prescribed by a doctor, when Plymouth Community Homes found out, they ordered the dog had to be rehomed.
There is a section in the Plymouth Community Homes Pets Policy that states pets are allowed if they are medically prescribed (Picture: SWNS)

‘If they moved me somewhere else I would not know anybody.

‘My neighbours all agree that this is disgusting. Tammy has not been any trouble at all.

‘There have not been any complaints. I just don’t understand it.

‘They allow deaf dogs, so why not her?

On a hot summer day, fill up an inflatable pool with water and ice.

‘I have got a bit of encouragement from the judge. I had stopped eating as I was so anxious – but hopefully I can start again. She seemed to care.’

Dr Michaela Stoffregen, who prescribed Tammy, has written numerous letters to Plymouth Community Homes to convince them to allow the beagle to stay.

She said: ‘The dog is very important for [Christopher’s] mental health and reduces his anxiety and loneliness.

Christopher Palmer outside the Plymouth Crown Court in Devon, with his dog Tammy. 26/11/2019 See SWNS story SWSYevict. A vulnerable man has been hauled to court and faces eviction over his medically prescribed 'emotional support companion dog' - despite doctors demanding he be allowed to keep it. Christopher Palmer, 63, has suffered years of depression, anxiety and mental health problems - leaving him socially isolated with suicidal tendencies. But things changed when Christopher's doctor prescribed him an emotional support and mental wellness animal companion - a beagle called Tammy in December 2018. Despite Christopher's pet being prescribed by a doctor, when Plymouth Community Homes found out, they ordered the dog had to be rehomed.
Christopher’s doctor has written many letters arguing his case (Picture: SWNS)

‘I think it would be quite cruel to take the dog away from him and equally he wouldn’t be able to cope well with finding a new place.

‘He has severe mental health issues and his dog keeps him stable.

‘I strongly advise that everything possible has to be done to let Christopher keep his little dog, as it is a lifeline for him.

‘A move would be disastrous to his mental health in my opinion. He has already expressed suicidal thought about this situation.

‘I am extremely concerned about his mental state and taking away his dog will likely worsen his suicidal thoughts and might well tip him over the edge.’

At the court hearing, solicitor Vincent Davis – representing Plymouth Community Homes – said the tenant was ‘in breach of his tenancy for keeping a dog in the property’.

Make Your Own Pet Bed Out of a Sweatshirt. Want to give your dog a nice comfy spot to sleep without having to buy a dog bed from the store? Make them this super cool dog bed out of a sweatshirt & pillow.

He said he should be required to remove the dog ‘within seven days of servicing the injunction order’.

He added: ‘He has been offered the choice between re-homing the dog, or moving to an alternative premises that has its own garden.

‘Most tenants would jump to move from a multi-storey block to their own garden but Mr Palmer has not engaged with that.

‘Various efforts have been made but he has not engaged with the process. This is a long standing policy that was adopted in 2011/2012.

‘The reasons why you cannot keep pets in a high rise flat is the nuisance it causes to other neighbours.

‘We recognise the benefits to having a pet but to have one in such close proximity to others causes problems with urine and faeces in communal areas.’

He also highlighted the problem a dog could cause during an evacuation, saying there was ‘good reason’ for the rule.

Judge Vanessa Priddis said: ‘If Mr Palmer was blind and had a guide dog would we say the same?Dog with tail growing out of his head!!'Unicorn puppy' with tail growing out of his head is rescued from the street

‘He is disabled and ten minutes to deal with and make a decision on this is not fair. There are technical and legal issues to consider.

Cover Up Scratch Marks on Furniture with a Walnut. Do you have a few scratch marks on your wooden furniture? You can cover them up by rubbing a walnut over them. The natural oils in walnuts seep into wood, making them a simple way to help cover up small scratches in your furniture.

‘I have to consider his mental state and if he understands that. This has been on-going since February and I need time to take proper advice.

‘We don’t want to rush it. I am not going to sacrifice dealing with the case fairly for speed.’

One of his neighbours, who accompanied him to court, said: ‘The housing association may think they are legally right, but they are morally extremely wrong.

‘I am a neighbour and there has never been any problem with the dog. She is very well behaved and there have never been any issues.

‘No one has complained so why are they doing this to him?’

The case will resume on 9 January 2020.